News RSS Feed


Wind power plan cut by half

11:16am Saturday 31st May 2008

comment Comments (7)   Have your say »


A CONTROVERSIAL wind farm plan for Purbeck is seeing the number of turbines in the scheme slashed from the originally proposed six down to just three.

This was revealed by the district council's planning officer Alan Davies at the monthly meeting of the planning board.

He told councillors there was a considerable amount of work to be done before the scheme was brought before them with any recommendation from the planners.

He added: "We have had a letter in the last few days from the applicants wishing to reduce the number of turbines down to three."

He said planners were still considering whether that could be dealt with as an amendment to the original application - or whether that would have to be withdrawn and a completely a fresh plan submitted to the council. He said: "We will take some advice on that and report back to the planning board and the applicants."

Planning board chairman Coun Peter Wharf said the eventual debate on the application when it came before councillors was expected to be lengthy - with significant comments likely from members of the public.

He said if there were to be a large number of people potentially wanting to put their views to the council on the application, it might lead to a special planning board meeting to focus on just the one subject.

Public interest might also lead to an evening meeting or a special venue being arranged.

He urged councillors not to debate the merits of the proposal until the planning process had run its course and it came before the board for a decision.

Councillors have asked for a visit to a similar-sized wind farm so they can assess the proposal's potential impact on the Purbeck landscape.

The application is from the Wimborne-based company Infinergy - a joint venture between leading property agents Savills and Dutch company Koop Duurzame Energie - for a wind farm project with local landowner Will Bond at Masters Pit in East Stoke to the north west of Wareham.

The application for six turbines standing 410 ft tall, with a height to the hubs of 84 metres and a blade tip 125 metres above ground level, was submitted back in late March for what has been named the Alaska Wind Farm on a site off the Puddletown Road.

Opponents of the scheme have attacked it as an environmental disaster - though the turbines would be in an area scarred by quarrying they would be seen from as far away as Corfe Castle to the south. A group was also formed backing the plans as a green energy solution.

Nine metre turbine may be installed at school

PLANNERS have recommended a proposal for a nine metre-high wind turbine to be built in the grounds of a primary school.

Subject to councillors' approval, the turbine will be installed next to the playing field at Southwell Primary School on Portland.

The turbine's blades would be 5.5 metres in diameter and the structure would be erected 25 metres south of the main school building.

Members of Dorset County Council's planning committee will vote on the plans when they meet on Friday.

A single letter of representation objecting to the turbine was received from a resident living 80 metres away.

Concerns were raised about the amount of noise it might generate - potentially disturbing schoolchildren who would be studying in nearby classrooms.

But the county council's head of planning said the turbine's predicted decibel level is 45 if the turbine rotates at five metres per second and 65 if it rotates at 20 metres per second.

A car passing 20 metres away and travelling at 40 miles per hour would be equivalent to 70 to 80 decibels.

It can therefore be seen that the noise emanating from the proposed wind turbine would be less than normal background levels for dwellings located around the school,' the report says.

The nearest houses are 50 metres to the east and 60 metres to the south of the wind turbine site, the report says.

The wind turbine, which will be placed on the south west side of the building, is designed to help the school use renewable energy to reduce its carbon footprint.

Councillors will be asked to consider the plans in the light of government energy policy, which encourages the generation of energy from renewable resources.

But they will be asked to weigh up their decision against environment policies to maintain and enhance the quality and diversity of the Dorset landscape.

Elsewhere on the island, Brackenbury Infant School, in Fortuneswell, has submitted plans to install a wind turbine.


Your Say YourDorset Echo

local resident, weymouh says...
11:21am Sun 1 Jun 08

All these greenies want to save the planet but when it comes to positive action they all start wingeing. I bet if they were building corfe castle today they would all object on the ground that it it would spoil their view.

Tru Belle, purbeck says...
1:06pm Sun 1 Jun 08

local resident wrote:
All these greenies want to save the planet but when it comes to positive action they all start wingeing. I bet if they were building corfe castle today they would all object on the ground that it it would spoil their view.
Embattled or embittered-which then?

Giant turbines will not fit in as snugly as Corfe Castle did/or would if it were built now!, but at least it had a purpose, whereas these 420ft turbines need some wind do they not? What use are three going to do besides create huge long shadows being seen from every point in Dorset which would be okay if we really need a quick fix with alternative energy, go the whole hog and smother every hill, cliff, hollow, ridge, back garden front garden, field ,edges of recreation grounds etc etc. Guess what ,if you think these will provide you with cheap electricity- think again please. We have seen the very best days of our lives now. We all now need deeper pockets or fatter bank accounts!!

Pete, Wareham says...
11:04am Mon 2 Jun 08

As a 'green' campaigner living about 3 miles from the proposed site, I am very much in favour.

Wessex Lass, Dorchester says...
12:12pm Mon 2 Jun 08

If we are all supposed to be going green then why object? Must be far better than looking at one of the new nuclear power stations or living next to somewhere where they have to store the waste. I would rather have a turbine (and I have lived near them in Cornwall). Perhaps a better idea would be to provide every house with solar panels. Probably the same cost as building a power station and so much greener.

maximus, Weymouth says...
1:43pm Mon 2 Jun 08

They wouldn't be planning to put them up if they didn't get huge amounts of taxpayer's money in grants from the Govt. As well as building these things, they also have to provide some way of connecting to the National Grid - more pylons and wires going across the countryside. It wouldn't be so bad if they could provide power 24 hours of every day but I don't think that they work very well when there is no wind or too much of the wrong sort of wind.

Pete, Wareham says...
5:02pm Mon 2 Jun 08

what grants are those then? I want one for my garden!

Shy-Talk, Weymouth says...
5:44pm Mon 2 Jun 08

Pete go to this web site http://www.energysav
ingtrust.org.uk/ I got 50% grant for Solar PV (photovoltaic) uses energy from the sun to create electricity to run appliances and lighting. PV systems produce no greenhouse gases and each kWp can save approximately 455kg of carbon dioxide emissions per year, adding up to about 11 tonnes over a system's lifetime.


Comments are closed on this article.

Local Advertisers


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »