News RSS Feed


Anger as cost of relief road soars

8:25am Wednesday 20th August 2008

comment Comments (19)   Have your say »


WEYMOUTH'S long-awaited relief road has come under fire from campaigners angered by spiralling costs.

The Campaign for Better Transport (CBT) pressure group, formerly called Transport 2000, claimed the cost of the controversial scheme had leapt by 46 per cent since it was introduced in December 2003.

The route's £84 million price tag puts it fifth in the CBT's table of the most expensive local authority roads.

But Dorset County Council highways chief Andy Ackerman said the increase was simply down to uncontrollable external factors.

South Dorset MP Jim Knight blamed campaigners delaying the initiative for the rising costs. The fresh attack on the road comes as supporters await the result of a public inquiry into the scheme.

The CBT said the cost of the Weymouth proposal had soared from £55 million when it was first tabled nearly five years ago.

It also revealed the total cost of the routes included in the Government's road-building programme had increased to more than £8 billion.

CBT roads and climate campaigner Richard George said: "The Government has consistently failed to keep the spiralling cost of road building under control.

"It cannot expect the taxpayer to pick up a £8.12 billion bill for a collection of expensive white elephants that will increase traffic, pollution and carbon emissions."

But Mr Ackerman said the £29 million increase in the price of the Weymouth Relief Road was down to rising construction costs.

He said: "The rise can be accounted for by inflation, which has been running very high.

"It's factors out of anyone's control such as steel prices and oil prices, which have gone up very quickly.

"The fact the process has been slowed has also added to the cost. If we'd started building the road last year it would have cost £4 million less."

Mr Ackerman said some design aspects of the route had been honed' during the public inquiry process but that minor alterations were not to blame for the rise. He said Dorset County Council was still very confident' of getting a positive decision on the road and starting initial work soon.

"We're very proud of the scheme we've come up with," he added.

"It's one which will really add value environmentally, as well as in transport terms."

Mr Knight hit out at the CBT for complaining about rising costs.

He said: "It's the constant drip feed of frivolous challenges coming in from such organisations that's delaying a decision on the road.

"Delay increases the cost because of inflation.

"If they're worried about rising costs why don't they just let local people have their way and let us build this road."


Your Say YourDorset Echo

derek, dorset says...
8:49am Wed 20 Aug 08

Oh no ( play hitchcock music ) , its back aghhhhhh ( play jaws music )

We need new films :-
The relief road
The revenge of the relief road.
Relief road strikes back.

Given the current fuel problems , it should be cancelled and the money for a more suitable from of transport .
Why invest in a dinosaur. The days of the motor car are numbered.

swibley, weymouth says...
9:16am Wed 20 Aug 08

How much did the 'objectors' delays add to the final cost of the relief road? Taking about objectors does one of the founders of the objectors still drive his little red sports car to B&Q car park, park it there for the day and go off on his bike, returning at night to do the opposite trip. Could that possibly be because the Dorchester Road is so busy and dangerous for bikes?

Mikeman, Portland says...
10:29am Wed 20 Aug 08

Its about time the so called do-gooders excepted defeat in good grace the people of Weymouth want this road & it is needed, we have excepted a compromise in so much as it has shrunk from a proper dual carriageway ( which it should have been ) to a little single carriageway. It would have been a lot cheaper if the likes of CBT & other stupid groups had kept their noses out in the first place, they can all go & find another project to complain about & jack the price of that up. What we should be talking about now is an east west extension of the M27 to link up with the M5 that would give them something to get their teeth into.

Dorset Beachcomber, Preston, Weymouth says...
10:53am Wed 20 Aug 08

Mr Knight is quite right. The only reason the cost of the road has risen is because of the delays caused mainly by the objectors like the CBT. Most of them don't live anywhere near here and don't miss hospital appointments etc because they're caught up in the present traffic jams on the A354.

paulkc, weymouth says...
11:16am Wed 20 Aug 08

Tunnel Vision....

Why is there only the choice of a road or no road? Are there any groups out there supporting a tunnel - no disruption on the surface and if it ran under the ridgeway - it could save fuel.

yogi, weymouth says...
11:19am Wed 20 Aug 08

Lets hope for more delays so the road into a cul de sac will become far too costly to build...

Perry Winkle, Weymouth says...
11:30am Wed 20 Aug 08

The likes of CBT simply do not live in the real world.

What do they think this place is - a miniscule rural hamlet?

techie, Weymouth says...
1:10pm Wed 20 Aug 08

paulkc wrote:
Tunnel Vision....

Why is there only the choice of a road or no road? Are there any groups out there supporting a tunnel - no disruption on the surface and if it ran under the ridgeway - it could save fuel.
If you read the Environmental Statement (available for download from dorsetforyou.com you will find that at least one alignment involving a tunnel was evaluated.

Dorset Boy, Wilds of Dorset says...
2:08pm Wed 20 Aug 08

Perhaps the objectors would like to dip into their own pockets to pay for the rise in millions instead of putting the burden on the tax payer. Get on and build the road!!!!

Ask Archie, Weymouth says...
3:25pm Wed 20 Aug 08

It IS the delays caused by the objectors that has increased the cost.If it had been built 10years ago it would have cost less than half the current estimate.Still expensive but Weymouth may have by now been a thriving town and not one on the brink with over 20 empty shops in the town.Unless it's built we will be the laughing stock of the world when the olympic's arrive.I'm sure visitors will be overjoyed when it takes them over an hour to get from Chafeys rounabout to top of the ridgeway,as it did me last saturday.The greenies need to remember that less polution is caused by steady moving traffic than stationary vehicles.

tiger, preston says...
4:50pm Wed 20 Aug 08

Perhaps the objectors would like to dip into their own pockets to pay for the rise in millions instead of putting the burden on the tax payer. Get on and build the road!!!!

Perhaps the government should finance the entire project out of the various taxes and duties levied on the motorist.

genghis, portland says...
5:00pm Wed 20 Aug 08

yogi wrote:
Lets hope for more delays so the road into a cul de sac will become far too costly to build...
Yeah! As Weymuff is a cul de sac it would also makes sense to scrap the existing roads into the town as well then? Nobody wants a road into a cul de sac after all.

Ask Archie, Weymouth says...
5:00pm Wed 20 Aug 08

Just a short note 17.00hrs 20th August 2008.A354 at a standstill due to volume of traffic."Releif road now" I think so, don't you.

chanticleer, locked on says...
1:28am Thu 21 Aug 08

Ask Archie wrote:
It IS the delays caused by the objectors that has increased the cost.If it had been built 10years ago it would have cost less than half the current estimate.Still expensive but Weymouth may have by now been a thriving town and not one on the brink with over 20 empty shops in the town.Unless it's built we will be the laughing stock of the world when the olympic's arrive.I'm sure visitors will be overjoyed when it takes them over an hour to get from Chafeys rounabout to top of the ridgeway,as it did me last saturday.The greenies need to remember that less polution is caused by steady moving traffic than stationary vehicles.
You conveniently forget that if the road was built ten years ago it would have been the totally discredited Green Route. You must remember it, the DCC's fantasy route which involved much of the proposed road becoming a dual-carriageway, an inflated and unpracticable plan which caused much amusement in Whitehall.

I'd advise you to consider that much of the delay which so concerns you was caused by DCC'S lack of foresight by letting their original compulsory purchase lapse.


Alan Barrington, says...
11:32am Thu 21 Aug 08

Which is better?:

Being sat in a traffic jam for 1 hr trying to get from Dorchester to Weymouth, with your engine running at the most uneconomical speed, or driving at the engines design economical speed for 10 minutes ?

Green campaigners haven't got an argument. If this road doesn't get built then Weymouth will be a laughing stock and the subject of ridicule at the 2012 Olympics - which won't do the local economy any good seeing as we don't have an economy anymore apart from tourism.

nige, dorchester says...
5:37pm Thu 21 Aug 08

The London 2012 Olympic sailing venue at W&P will be completed and ready for the Olympics by Christmas. I do wonder, how the non fee paying spectators are supposed to watch the sailing. Without a road we will be laughed out of court,

Leo, weymouth says...
8:33pm Thu 21 Aug 08

Not really, nige of dorchester. No new road was ever suggested as necessary for the Olympics. If you look at the original Olympic bid (Candidate File) you will see that all spectators are to arrive by 'public transport, cycle of foot'.

nige, dorchester says...
9:00pm Thu 21 Aug 08

It's not the spectators that I am worroed about. How are the Teams supposed to get there? 20 teams, each with 15-30 staff. What about the press? Will they arrive on bikes? I think that Lord Sebastian is correct when he says that this isn't going to be Beijing. Far from it mate.

swibley, weymouth says...
12:38pm Sat 23 Aug 08

If the ant-road campaigners can help me with this problem I will be eternally gateful. As a resident of the Dorcgester Road for the past 22 years I do not mind the heavy car traffic but I am fed up of having my house shaken by the continual stream of lorries passing by both in the day time and through the night with only 2 hours break between 2-4am. Somehow I do not think public transport will help this situation. I need relief NOW !!P.S. Take a look at the 'new ' road surface...it's already looking ropey after only being down for a couple of months at the most.

Comments are closed on this article.

Local Advertisers


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »