News RSS Feed


Purbeck wind farm protest gathers momentum


A PRESSURE group demonstrated against a proposed wind turbine in Purbeck and then made off with the developer’s information leaflets.

The public rally by the Dorset Against Rural Turbines (Dart) group and the county branch of the Campaign to Protect Rural England (CPRE) opposed plans for Alaska Wind Farm in Master’s Pit, East Stoke.

A dozen people gathered with placards and shouted ‘wind turbines make bats lungs explode’, ‘no giant wind turbines here’ outside the Springfield Country Hotel near Wareham.

The demonstration coincided with a public exhibition on Infinergy’s revised plan, which has reduced six turbines to four.

Dave Littlewood of Rushton Lane, East Stoke, said the scheme had already devalued his house £75,000-£100,000. He said: “No one’s particularly against wind turbines, it’s just where they’re being located next to houses.

“My house has a beautiful backdrop, that’s what I paid for and now everything I’ve worked for is being taken from me.

“The noise will affect us as well.”

President of Dorset CPRE Terry Stewart said 410ft turbines would be a ‘massive visual blot’ on an Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty (AONB) and wind power, being unpredictable, would require fossil fuel back up.

He added the developers’ ‘massive subsidies’ were ‘£1 billion’ this year.

Mr Stewart and another protester then made off with Infinergy’s information packs from the display.

Infinergy project director Herb Lindlahr said: “They came in here shouting, stole everything and legged it.”

He denied making a billion pounds as ‘total rubbish’ and said they could only claim Renewable Obligation Certificates (ROCs) ‘per electricity unit we put into the grid and sell.’ Mr Lindlahr said the proposed site was a quarry, outside an AONB, and they had worked with statutory bodies including Natural England to minimise the effect on wildlife.

He said the scheme could supply enough energy for 11-14 per cent of Dorset’s targets.

He added: “Global warming is not science fiction, it’s brutal reality.

“We must act now in our own backyards to secure a good future for the next generation.”

Infinergy intends to submit a new planning application to Purbeck District Council before the end of the year.

Comments(12)

Albo says...
8:39am Tue 4 Nov 08

So, basically, the CPRE-led protests are both childish and based on incorrect information. Where have we heard this before?

maximus says...
9:27am Tue 4 Nov 08

Quote "He said the scheme could supply enough energy for 11-14 per cent of Dorset’s targets"
what happens when the wind doesn't blow or blows too hard? Zero output.

Never Wrong says...
10:54am Tue 4 Nov 08

Dave Littlewood of Rushton Lane, East Stoke, said the scheme had already devalued his house £75,000-£100,000. He said: “No one’s particularly against wind turbines, it’s just where they’re being located next to houses.

“My house has a beautiful backdrop, that’s what I paid for and now everything I’ve worked for is being taken from me.

That sounds like a typical nimby who wants everything including a view as long as its in the right place. What a selfish B******d..

mikeman says...
11:14am Tue 4 Nov 08

So am I right in thinking that this group would be quite happy if they put these turbines in the midlands & sent the electricity down here by cable (underground of course) talk about not in my back yard. We do live in a beautiful part of the country but that does not excuse us from development whether that be wind turbines or houses, some people seem to think that we should create some kind of protection bubble & only let in things we want, why not close Poole docks for a start & get rid of all those nasty lorries and turn it into a big marina & wildlife haven, We could rename Dorset Utopia & limit entry to people with more than a million in the bank, I am sorry if I have digressed but these nimby’s really P*** me off.

maximus says...
11:30am Tue 4 Nov 08

mikeman, Portland,
This group, along with many others think that these wind turbines are just not very efficient and are poor value for our money (since much of the costs are from government grants otherwise the pay back period for a wind turbine is many many years). They are inefficient and the money would be much better sent on a modern nuclear powered generator, these have been used in submarines where they appear to be relatively trouble free.

Genghis says...
11:57am Tue 4 Nov 08

Maximus, the CPRE campaign against anything and everything. They campaigned against the relief road, they campaign against wind turbines, they campaign against tidal power. What makes you think they will be in favour of nuclear power?

These idiots won't be happy until we're all back living in caves and living a Stone Age livestyle.

maximus says...
12:46pm Tue 4 Nov 08

OK Genghis, Portland, I share your sentiments about CPRE but that does not make wind turbines the best answer to the 'soon to be' shortage of power generation. This short-sighted government seems bent on wind generation when perhaps water powered generators might be a better solution, this includes wave generators and also bringing back the installation of water wheel or turbine generators, both in England and neighbouring Scotland and Wales.

mikeman says...
1:33pm Tue 4 Nov 08

Maximus I agree with your comments about alternative power but it doesn’t matter which way you go there is a protest group out there just waiting to pounce, its very much a no win situation. But the fact is we need power & quickly, I personally have my doubts about wind power & wave power is still very much in its infancy & with water levels changing etc it could be a bit of a lottery. So I would go down the nuclear route & also keep a close eye on coal power as we still have vast stocks of coal that are now financially viable.

Scolopax says...
5:19pm Tue 4 Nov 08

Nuclear and Wave power are nice solutions, wind-farm may not be best efficiency but it's up and running in a matter of a few weeks. (and when it's finished with does not leave nasties behind)

mark@greenhill says...
5:35pm Tue 4 Nov 08

Am I on my own in thinking that Wind Farms are actually very pleasant to look at?
I drive all over the south west and the wind farms in Cornwall are incredibly peacefull and relaxing to watch.
I for one would not object to living near one.
But, as has been proved on here before, I also would not interfere in someone elses issue, unlike the protesters against the relief road, who think it's fine to object even though they live a hundred miles away and are therefore unaffected by the damage caused by not building it.

Gladys says...
7:44pm Tue 4 Nov 08

I agree with Mark: wind farms are pleasant to look at. They are also remarkably quiet.

I would far rather live next to a wind farm than a coal-fired or nuclear-powered facility.

fishman68 says...
9:13am Wed 5 Nov 08

There are some really selfish and naïve comments from the anti-lobby here. The reality is this country needs to find alternative ways of generating sustainable power. What exactly is the problem? I personally would be more than happy to live next to a wind turbine; they add interest to the landscape and in some locations even attract tourism and picnickers too!
It is complete nonsense that the sitting of a wind turbine would take £75-100k off the value of the property.

Meanwhile back on planet ‘Earth’ nobody can sell their house anyway, due the credit crunch/property slump. Yet the only argument is a few selfish and tunnelvision proprietors couldn’t give stuff about contributing towards green power generation for all they would prefer the planet goes down the pan instead.

We all need to take steps to pursue green energy producing technologies, and sadly most of the negative comments are purely focused around greed and selfish needs rather than dealing with the facts and implications of climate change.

Time to grow up and smell the coffee, would you prefer to live next to a wind turbine or a Nuclear power station we are rapidly running out of options and time in which to act.


WIND OF PROTEST: Terry Stewart from CPRE, above, with people protesting against the proposed Purbeck wind farm WIND OF PROTEST: Terry Stewart from CPRE, above, with people protesting against the proposed Purbeck wind farm

Most popular






Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »

Local Businesses