News RSS Feed


Weymouth nightclub attacker admits using bottle was 'unreasonable'


DORCHESTER Crown Court was told that Doyle admitted lashing out at Stephen Clark, but did not realise he had a glass bottle in his hand at the time.

Peter Spink, prosecuting, said Doyle was out with fellow sailors on the night in question and one of his group was exchanging words with Mr Clark.

Doyle then became involved in the altercation and struck out at Mr Clark hitting him in the head and causing glass to hit Marc Williamson in the face.

Mr Spink said: “Mr Williamson was nearby trying to calm things down.”

In a basis of plea read out at the sentencing hearing, Doyle claimed he did not realise he had a bottle in his hand at the time.

He said: “I did not appreciate at the time of the instinctive strike that I had a bottle in my hand.

“On reflection the use of the bottle was unreasonable.”

Edward Elton, mitigating, said Doyle, of Fordenbridge Road, Sunderland, had not been in trouble with the courts before this incident but was ‘emotionally troubled at the time’.

He said Doyle had recently suffered the loss of a close friend during his naval service as well as his grandfather and grandmother.

Doyle had just been medically discharged from the Navy due to abnormally low lung capacity.

As well as imposing a suspended sentence Judge Jarvis also imposed a six-month curfew requirement and ordered that Doyle carry out 200 hours of unpaid community work.

Doyle was also ordered to pay £500 compensation to Mr Williamson, £150 to Mr Clark and a contribution of £300 towards prosecution costs.

Comments(6)

whatever66 says...
11:38am Mon 15 Mar 10

and still no plastic glasses this is becoming a weekly occurance now when will the landlords realise they are to partially to blame???? when they themselve's get glassed in the face and and recieve scar's????? get rid of glasses and bottles then this problem will dissapear......

dorch says...
12:55pm Mon 15 Mar 10

"i didn,t realise i had the bottle in my hand", no excuse, how long before we hear i didn,t realise the knife was in my hand.

Sidney Hall says...
2:48pm Mon 15 Mar 10

Let's all act with complete social disregard and hope that we get Judge Jarvis on the day.

CoogarUK.com says...
7:02pm Mon 15 Mar 10

@whatever66: It was a bottle not a glass but I do take your point. 'Not realising' he was holding a bottle at the time of lashing out is a lame excuse. The sentence should have been stronger, if any lessons are going to be learned from his inexcusable behaviour.

james the thirst says...
7:28pm Mon 15 Mar 10

I think he rather contradicted himself by saying 'on reflection the use of the bottle was unreasonable', seems like the judge has been to the 'any excuse will do school' unbelievable

whatever66 says...
1:43am Tue 16 Mar 10

CoogarUK.com wrote:
@whatever66: It was a bottle not a glass but I do take your point. 'Not realising' he was holding a bottle at the time of lashing out is a lame excuse. The sentence should have been stronger, if any lessons are going to be learned from his inexcusable behaviour.
yes it was a bottle but if the drinks were served in plastic glasses this would save the tax payers heaps of court cost as plastic cant be thrown that far and and certainley does not cause any damage.......


Martin Doyle arrives at Dorchester Crown Court Martin Doyle arrives at Dorchester Crown Court

Most popular






Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »

Local Businesses