Campaigns RSS Feed


Maternity and special care wards at county hospital face the axe

Simon and Kirstie Snow say their son Oscar would have died without Dorset County Hospital’s Special Care Baby Unit Simon and Kirstie Snow say their son Oscar would have died without Dorset County Hospital’s Special Care Baby Unit Buy this photo »

FEARS are growing for the future of the special care baby unit and maternity ward at Dorset County Hospital under new cost-saving proposals.

The Dorchester hospital is being forced to make millions of pounds’ worth of savings which are expected to threaten jobs and services.

Hospital sources said the accident and emergency department at the £45million complex should be safe but the maternity unit and special care baby unit are in the firing line.

The source said that the proposals include closing the special care baby unit and axing consultants in the maternity ward – with scans and appointments continuing in Dorchester but mums having to give birth elsewhere.

The proposals could also see patients undergoing elective surgery and urology patients being sent to Poole or Bournemouth hospitals.

One source said: “One proposal is to close the special care baby unit and for the maternity unit not to have a consultant, but to rely on midwives.

“There are apparently some services that are not used by many people.

“The problem is, all these things have to go somewhere else. Babies who are ill will have to go to elsewhere.”

Another source, a member of medical staff who wished to remain anonymous, added: “They will retain just an emergency department for the heart attacks, road crashes and other accidents.

“All the planned surgery and maternity will go elsewhere. If you get rid of the consultants you can’t run a maternity service so if you want to have your baby, it won’t happen here.”

The hospital’s NHS Foundation Trust has confirmed it is expecting debts of £7.3million by the end of the financial year.

Hospital bosses are drawing up a stringent recovery plan to make up the deficit and are expected to announce any cutbacks by the end of the month.

Another source added: “Surgeons are the most likely to lose their jobs because planned surgery will be sent off elsewhere.”

The source said staff are blaming the board of directors and are calling for their sacking.

“The staff are very upset and angry because they do their jobs as well as they possibly can.

“Some staff want to see the board all sacked.

“These people are trusted as public servants to run our local hospital and they may reduce it to a little cottage hospital with an emergency service.”

Derek Julian, a patient governor for the trust, has vowed to fight to secure the hospital’s future.

He said: “I will do my best for patients to see the good name of Dorchester hospital and the service given to the community is protected. We’re lucky to have a good hospital but we've got to all fight to retain it.”

The Dorset County NHS Foundation Trust has stressed the plans are not finalised yet.

A spokesman said: “We are aiming to finalise our recovery plan by the end of the month when we will inform our staff of any changes that may affect them.”

The spokesman added: “All services are being looked at as part of the trust’s recovery plan.”

Mr Julian is calling on more members of the public to join the foundation trust as volunteers.

A COUPLE whose son was cared for at the special care baby unit (SCBU) say he would have died without it.

Simon and Kirstie Snow were shocked at the prospect of the unit closing and fear many young lives could be lost.

Their son Oscar, now aged 19 months, was born six weeks early in March 2008 and weighed just 2lb 11oz, arriving by emergency C-section in the middle of the night. He was then cared for at SCBU for five weeks.

Mrs Snow said: “Without them he wouldn’t be here.

“The care we received there was second to none and I don’t know how we would have coped without them.

“They saved Oscar’s life.

“Without the SCBU I fear for the lives of unborn children and for their parents.

“Not every story has a happy outcome like ours and they’re there for the people whose babies don’t make it as well.”

Mr Snow added: “Without a doubt if he’d had to go to Poole, Bournemouth or Southampton it wouldn’t be the same story.”

When Oscar was in hospital, Mrs Snow breastfed her son remotely, expressing milk and taking it to him from their home in West Knighton, near Dorchester, every four hours.

“For me to make that journey to Southampton or Poole would have been horrendous,” she said.

The couple, who run the Snowflakes shop in Weymouth for expectant parents, are struggling to understand why the ward may close.

Mr Snow said: “I can’t believe it isn’t well used. Surely the statistics would speak for themselves if you look at the number of children’s lives they have saved.

“I just can’t see how they can justify it – whoever is making the decision needs to go and visit SCBU for a day and see what they do.

“Is it worth saving a few quid over potentially saving lives?”

The couple have praised the staff at SCBU who they said went above and beyond what anyone would expect. They have vowed to support the unit in any way they can.

Comments(25)

Tremendous Eddie Tremendouson says...
8:35am Thu 22 Oct 09

If these claims are true - it is quite simply scandalous! Nothing more nothing less!

Saying that I never agreed with the new hospital being in Dorchester - as agreed by 20,000 other petitioners who tried to get it built in Weymouth - where the overwhelming bulk of the local population is.




Dispirited says...
8:36am Thu 22 Oct 09

It is appalling if these cuts go ahead it will mean that many people living in Weymouth, Portland and surrounding areas will be denied prompt medical attention which is totally unacceptable. Bournemouth and Poole are excellent Hospitals but the travelling to get there for the elderly, pregnant and disabled,in fact for all, can be a nightmare. Like many I joined the Foundation Trust but have never received any communication, it would appear that this is just a paper excercise. As for the board of Directors one should not be surprised they are usually handpicked, yes men and women, how many "Joe Bloggs" are on this board representing the public.

boxfile says...
10:00am Thu 22 Oct 09

Tremendous Eddie Tremendouson wrote:
If these claims are true - it is quite simply scandalous! Nothing more nothing less! Saying that I never agreed with the new hospital being in Dorchester - as agreed by 20,000 other petitioners who tried to get it built in Weymouth - where the overwhelming bulk of the local population is.
Weymouth, Dorchester or Doncaster. If the same fools hold the purse strings the end result will be the same.

CherylBarrett says...
10:06am Thu 22 Oct 09

I was absolutely outraged when i read this morning's headlines on the front page about plans to scrap the Maternity and SCBU at DHC. If it wasn't for the staff up there - I could have lost my baby to. I had to travel from Weymouth to Dorchester to find out my baby was in distress and had to be delivered via section whilst i was under general aneathetic. What would happen to other mums who have to go through a simular proceedure???? they couldnt' be shipped off to another hospital. My baby wasn't breathing when he was born - it took the staff 10 minutes to revive him. I was also told that he might not survive the next 24/48 hours of his life.
the wards cannot be closed - think of all the hurt and pain other mums and dads would have to go through if they had a simular experience. I was thinking of having another child in the near future, but I fear the same thing will happen to me again, without the safety of these wards it has put the fear of god into me. this has bought back a lot of painful memories for me (my son is now 2 years old) and I really dont want anyone else to experience what I did, especially if they have to travel further to get to another hospital.

knivelhead51 says...
10:55am Thu 22 Oct 09

Undoubtably the insurance payout for the 1st parents to sue DHT will be easier thatn running at a £7million loss.These Idiots who run these things aren't business people they are just Lord or Lady Snobby who clearly have no idea on running such a complex operation.Living on Portland and having been a patient at DCH it was difficult enough for my wife who works nights to visit me in the now restricted visiting hours let alone the trip to Poole / Bournemouth if it happens . Absolutely Disgusted these peoposals must be fought

chellk says...
11:32am Thu 22 Oct 09

Absolutely a pathetic idea! Its bad enough getting to Dorchester from Portland let alone to Poole/Bournemouth. How many babies will be born with place of birth the A35. As for closing the SCBU again pathetic - again that would mean Poole/Bournemouth or Exeter (for those of us in the west of the county). These units at the best of times are overstretched without piling more work on to them. These closures SHOULD NOT happen and we shouldnt let them happen.

I don't think so! says...
11:34am Thu 22 Oct 09

Never mind. I'm sure the surrounding hospitals in Poole, Yeovil and Exeter will have space and spare cash to care for the 2,500+ mothers that Dorchester normally see a year, not to mention their babies. Clearly that is NOT going to happen. As a parent of a premature baby I know that the special care baby unit is excellent, essential, small and often over full (meaning that families do at times have to travel to other units as it is), please support their small voice if they are threatened with closure.

weymouthfox says...
12:34pm Thu 22 Oct 09

I used to work at DCH and the problem is that the Board see patients as files to be shunted wherever is most convenient to the budgets, not where it best suits the patient. The nonsense of hospitals being run like businesses is a New Labour government idea- so if you're 7 million in deficit, you simply sack that amount of staff! I agree the board should be sacked, they have presided over this mess. When I was at DCH, the Board were very remote characters with sky high salaries. There was no-one on the board representing patients.

585 says...
12:43pm Thu 22 Oct 09

The cuts should start at the top, get rid of some of the layers of paper-pushing managers and their staff. I assume that for each manager there is at least one secretary to run around after them.

captain slow says...
2:20pm Thu 22 Oct 09

I am disgusted to see that scbu may go from dorchester,our daughter hayley was born at southampton at 26weeks,she was there 4 4 weeks and it was a nightmare,yes she had xcellent treatment but mine and my hubbies lives were nightmare.after 4 weeks she came back 2 dorch,we were able 2 come and go as we pleased and only 5 miles from home,she also was taken care of very well,all staff were brill,i sometimes take my children back 2 dorch,2006 we had our second daughter demi,she was born at 35weeks and stayed in scbu for 2 weeks,once again scbu were brill!!It has really upset me to read todays articule that scbu may go,im sure you can save money looking elsewhere in the hospital,we were fortunate that we could stay at s,hampton,but it was horrid as we stayed in a house with other sick peoples relatives,we just wanted 2 be at dorch with our baby we didnt want 2 be miles away from home,its bad enough that we have children at this stage,never mind being away from home.Thankyou Mandy.

portlandboy says...
2:37pm Thu 22 Oct 09

What was the reason given to us all when Weymouth and District hospital was "closed"? I think they told us that a "central" hospital in Dorchester was the only way to keep the costs under control and that everyone would benefit from having everything in one place.
The reality has always been that a few benefitted by building and maintaining it, a few more by "managing" it and now the majority of us will suffer because of it. Why did the Trust battle to win the urology back from Poole? And why did Jan Bergman depart so suddenly?
Answers will be forthcoming, I'm sure

pennyforthem says...
4:52pm Thu 22 Oct 09

Please will the people at the top STOP messing about with things!
When the hospital was built it was for convenience and so it was in the County Town, what has changed? Stop wasting money on rubbish stuff and put it into frontline staff and cleaners. Is this all revenge because they were caught out spending to much on temporary staff? Time the pen pushers started to justify the ideas they come up with.

barroness says...
4:53pm Thu 22 Oct 09

i am so disgusted by this story as a mum of 5 and haveing 4 of them goin into s.c.b.u at some point from haveing a 9yr old that had feeding problems goin into there at less then a day old for 2 weeks and i have a 7 yr old that was in there for 2 months due to growing probs and feeding problems to haveing my 5 yr old was grunting when born so speat 6 hours in there and then to have my 3 yr old who i had 5 weeks early at 2 pound 15 who i had to go to basingstoke due to shortage of bed for a week abit then he was moved down to dorch for the remaining time which was 3 and abit months and he came home with a feeding tube still in his nose to feed him and if it wasnt for s.c.b.u staff i would not of known what to do and to help him and both s.c.b.u are brill i am so greatful to them both for what they have done for my kids and thats why i feel this should never happen and for them to say they are getting rid of the department as they say due to money cuts and coz people only basically **** in then go is disgusting and by how i read it saying it is hardly used now that why i had to be sent to another hospital due to hospital bed shortage in s.c.b.u so for them to say that is so wrong and im sorry but i feel that something bad will happen if we lose eather of the departments there is no way we can do with loseing them futher away due to where they are is far anoth from my experiance i feel we need it to be closer so much can happen from here to dorch as for them moveing dont bare thinking of so if there is anything i can help by doin i will be there i feel so strong on this due to my kids being in there i would do anything to stop it i would also like to say how with out the midwifes and the consultant my kids would more then likely not be here so i am greatful for all of them and for what they have done for me and my kids over the yrs and think it is mental to even consider even moveing or loseing any of them s.c.b.u and maternity x

Lolacola says...
8:08pm Thu 22 Oct 09

The Echo have really surpassed themselves this time. If you read the article propoerly it says that all services are being looked at which given the financial problem at the county hospital is not surprising. Why is it OK for the Echo to use socially irresponsible journalism to scare the public witless. It clearly states that "The Dorset County NHS Foundation Trust has stressed the plans are not finalised yet." But hey lets believe that all managers are self obbsessed liars then we can justifiably condem them!

We know the hospital provides really good care and that care is managed by the same management team that the majority of commentors to this web site have condemend as useless at best and the landed gentry at worst.

Its time we woke up to the fact that this is sensationalism at its worst and the only people to suffer are the public who believe the stories printed in the Echo. After all what self respecting editor would allow a picture of a vulnerable baby in an incubator to be printed next to a page of semi naked men!!

Whatamum says...
3:41am Fri 23 Oct 09

As a mum of 2 babies afer a lot of struggling to have kids, all I can say is I wish that the "top brass " should have a walk down to these two wonderful wards to have a look at just how busy and dedicated the staff are, without their help my Son who is now 6 would not have made it into this world. They often do more than is needed to just make you feel safe and informed about the well ebing of your baby. I know for certain that most Midwifes stay on after their shift has finished because they are dedicated to their patients. But that is a fair statetment to say about most of the nurses in the Hospital. We always here bad things about DCH, but how ofter do good things be reported?? Come on lets think about this seriously, if we got rid of a few more "pen pushers" the Hospital would probably be in a much better financial position. So Thank you DCH for helping with my Children.

Dispirited says...
8:58am Fri 23 Oct 09

Surely this is the right time for the Echo to put this proposed closure in the public domain. This gives the general public time to make their comments which hopefully those that are involved in the decision making will take note of. Would we prefer any decisions relating to our care be made in secret and only announced when it is to late for us users to make any stand.

Zoe Thompson says...
8:59am Fri 23 Oct 09

I was totally outraged when I saw todays article about shutting SCBU. Without this unit my son probably wouldn't be here today. He was born 5 1/2 weeks early weighing only 3lb 12, and had to spend the first 2 1/2 weeks in SCBU. I don't know what I would have done without the unit and its fantastic staff. Obviously the people who taken this decision have never been in my position. while I was there the unit was at bursting point and they having to send babies to other hospitals so how can they possibly shut it!!!!!!!

julieward says...
9:10am Fri 23 Oct 09

I live in weymouth now but when i first moved down south i lived on portland.i had two children who where both born at the old Portwey Hospital on Wyke Rd. We moved away for a time and came back to find that portwey had been closed and all maternity services had been moved to dorchester. i am a nurse and worked at both weymouth and district and dorset county hospitals. i was one of the nurses that help move SCBU from the old blue and red building into the new wing. that was simply a case of wheeling the babies and their belonging through the corridores of the hospital it was quick very well organised and no disuption to the babies care.
Closing SCBU and the MAT UNIT would mean mothers and babies being bundeled into ambulances with medical staff and taken on a 1-2 hour journey depending on dorset roads and awful traffic.
My youngest daughter is pregnant at the moment and has to go to the MAT UNIT at least twice a week for monitoring which usually takes her approx one and half hours if they move the unit to any of the nearest hospitals it would take her all afternoon and then some.
if the hospital has to save some money get rid of pencil pushers, stop moving offices around or renting spaces in other buildings. DCH use to be a nice hospital to work in on any ward i have friends who still work there and say that i am better of out of the system. All the nurses and doctors have my vote to keep the MATUNIT and SCBU at dorchester.

dorsetdog says...
11:12am Fri 23 Oct 09

585 wrote:
The cuts should start at the top, get rid of some of the layers of paper-pushing managers and their staff. I assume that for each manager there is at least one secretary to run around after them.
I fully agree with you.Have you overlooked the Deputy Manager , his secretary and the under secretary?

Bluelady says...
7:48pm Fri 23 Oct 09

"Staff want to see the board sacked"

We the tax payer, their employers should be putting through a vote on no confidence in the present board!

I am informed that the 'fat cat' chief executive of DCH is more business minded than patient care, however it would seem to me that any business he ran would go under through bankrupcy!

However, we cannot put all the blame on senior management, the present government plays a vital role with regards to health funding and they intend cutting health budgets even further.


chav scum says...
10:12am Sat 24 Oct 09

The article does not read particularly well- it is not clear which points are facts and which are merely rumours, published by the Echo to shift copies.... I would be thoroughly surprised if MAT and SCBU at DCH were to close.

Tremendous Eddie Tremendouson says...
4:24pm Sat 24 Oct 09

chav scum wrote:
The article does not read particularly well- it is not clear which points are facts and which are merely rumours, published by the Echo to shift copies.... I would be thoroughly surprised if MAT and SCBU at DCH were to close.
The abortion clinic has already moved to Poole, so isn't it logical that the rest of the maternity sevices will follow?

DizzyDon says...
7:59pm Sat 24 Oct 09

One of my twins was 14months old when admitted to kingfisher ward with severe breathing difficulties. When she wasn't responding to treatment on the ward she was rushed downstairs to SCBU where she spent several nights. Thankfully she recovered but I'm positive she'd have had lasting damage had we had to make the trip to southampton. The suggestion that these wards be closed rather than getting rid of unecessary admin busybodies is pathetic.

chav scum says...
9:50pm Sat 24 Oct 09

Tremendous Eddie Tremendouson wrote:
chav scum wrote: The article does not read particularly well- it is not clear which points are facts and which are merely rumours, published by the Echo to shift copies.... I would be thoroughly surprised if MAT and SCBU at DCH were to close.
The abortion clinic has already moved to Poole, so isn't it logical that the rest of the maternity sevices will follow?
Abortion and maternity are separate anyway. Early pregnancy (pre- 20 weeks?) abortions- natural miscarriage that is - are Gynaes dept, and so I assume the same for arranged terminations.
I think logic suggests non-urgent appointment based services are more suitable to be moved to bigger hospitals, an hours drive away.
I think the very nature of the spontaneous need for MAT and SCBU services (and A&E, IC for example) requires that they must remain a geographically accessible service for all, regardless of cost.

Dispirited says...
2:59pm Sun 25 Oct 09

Logic does not come into it when people are unwell. Outside of Bournemouth and Poole we are the most densely populated area and in the coming years that population will increase.The roads will become more congested and bus and rail fares more expensive. We need services that we can access in our own area not one hour away. We must also not forget that Urology is under threat. This department deals with many of our elderly who are not always able to travel distances.

click2find

Most popular






About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree